The Game Cover
FeaturedReviewReviews
Take-Two Interactive

Red Dead Redemption 2 Review

By Benturpin40August 25, 2022

Rockstar Games

This review contains minor spoilers from the story – all major spoilers are not covered

Red Dead Redemption 2 (2018), Rockstar's most ambitious work to date, set in the western times of a country that is already done with outlaws, is both a eulogy and a place. You do not clear it. You keep a horse, a journal, and a debt to people who will not survive the decade.

Arthur Morgan rides into that decade already tired. The Van der Linde gang is famous, broke, and one bad winter away from splitting. What follows is the rare blockbuster that is interested in breakfast, in mud on a coat, in whether a man can be decent after he has stopped being free.

A country with weather

The map is the review. Valleys fog out by midmorning. Towns have opening hours. Strangers remember if you were rude, or if you helped, or if you simply rode past and let them have their day. Rockstar has built sandboxes before. This one has a climate.

Combat is weighty on purpose. A revolver is a decision, not a syllable. Cover, dead-eye, and the long reload all ask you to mean it. The better hours are the ones with no mission marker at all: a ride at dusk, a debt collected without a shot, a camp conversation you almost miss because you were brushing down a horse.

Minor story beats telegraph where loyalties are fraying. The game is honest about that early. It does not need a twist to make the gang feel doomed. The railroad, the pinkertons, and the ledger do that work in the background while you are still laughing at camp.

How it plays, years later

Controls are deliberate. Skinning, looting, and greeting take a beat longer than a modern checklist game would allow. That pace is the point, and it is also the thing that will lose some players in the first two hours. Stay. The mission design opens up once the camp has a rhythm, and the side stories — the widows, the veterans, the strange little errands — are where the writing is sharpest.

Visually it still embarrasses games that shipped after it. Not because of a spec sheet, but because light, cloth, and distance were directed. A street full of fog is a composition, not a particle slider. Faces hold a thought. Horses are characters with worse manners than the men.

The online half is a separate animal and not what this score is for. This review is about the single-player story, the one you can still start tonight and not come up for air until the epilogue decides who gets to keep a quiet life.

The standard it set

Plenty of open worlds copied the map size. Very few copied the manners: the way the game lets a scene finish, the way it trusts you to ride in silence, the way a minor kindness is allowed to matter without a pop-up telling you it mattered.

Red Dead Redemption 2 is Rockstar at full stretch. It is long, occasionally fussy, and unwilling to hurry a sunrise. It is also the western the medium had been threatening to make for twenty years, and it has not been replaced.