The Game Cover
ReviewReviews
Epic Games

Alan Wake 2 Review

By Leo VastNovember 9, 2023

Remedy Entertainment

Light on story specifics. The shape of the dread is discussed. The turns are not.

Alan Wake 2 is a forest that knows your name and a city that may be a manuscript. Remedy waits thirteen years and then refuses the easy version: no ironic wink big enough to let you off the hook, no action game hiding inside a flashlight. You walk. You read. You point a beam of light at something that should not be standing there and you decide if you have the bullets to mean it.

Saga Anderson gives the game its other pulse. Her case board is a mechanical joy, a detective fantasy that respects the player enough to let you pin the wrong thread and feel it. Alan's chapters are the nightmare of authorship, looping, vain, and increasingly sincere. Cutting between them is the structure, and the structure is the scare.

Light is the whole gun

Encounters are scarce enough to matter. You burn a darkness off a body and then you have a fight that is really a resource argument: was the flashlight worth the battery you spent being curious down that path? The Pacific Northwest around Cauldron Lake is soaked, ordinary, and wrong in the way good folk horror is wrong. Cabins are not content. They are decisions.

It is also a show-off, in the best sense. Live action, music, and a late-game sequence we will not describe are Remedy remembering it is allowed to be a band as well as a studio. Some chapters indulge that and lose tension. Most of them spend it so precisely that the indulgence feels earned.

Who should go into the trees

If you need a map full of activities, this is the wrong dark. If you want a horror game for adults who still like a puzzle and a shotgun, clear your evening and lower the lamps. Alan Wake 2 is the rare sequel that is braver than the original's reputation. It believes a story can be both a trap and a gift.